Rick wheeled down the ramp outside the courthouse, his stomach nearly as twisted as his legs. His wife Peg walked beside him, letting him roll himself because she knew he liked to be as independent as he could, but ready to jump in if needed. A daughter and son, both young adults, were right behind them, heads down with sorrowful looks on their faces.
While the judge and jury had given them the verdict they wanted, there was no relief or joy in it, because it would not bring her back.
The trial had been a few months ago, and it didn’t last long, because there was undeniable proof. Today’s hearing was something altogether different, something new. Something the country had only recently begun doing.
Without planning it, they paused under a tree near the parking lot, and they stood, or in Rick’s case, sat, in silence, each trying to sort out their own feelings, and wanting to support each other.
“Are you okay?” Rick asked Peg, taking her hand and looking up at her face flowing with tears. Beside them, Liv and Adam hugged, both also tearful.
Peg sniffed, “No, of course not.” Her face was flushed. “I know this is what we, well … wanted…”
Her voice trailed off. Rick found a tissue because he had had a feeling he would need them and handed her one. He handed some to Liv and Adam who both had rivers flowing from their eyes. They all patted their faces dry.
The thing about family is you don’t need to hide crying. And hugs helped.
Rick tried to say something else, but his throat constricted, so he shut up, and they all looked down.
After everyone seemed to be breathing normally and the faces were dry Rick tried his voice again, and this time it worked. “Does anyone want to go eat?”
Head shakes and a mumbled ‘no.’ Good, he didn’t want to eat either.
People were walking around them, some looking at them. Maybe they had been in the courtroom, and recognized the family. Time to get out of here.
As a group, they headed to the handicapped-accessible van. Peg was driving, Liv got in the front passenger seat and Adam helped Rick into the van and clamped the wheelchair in. Then he settled into the seat next to the wheelchair. A bit cramped, but Adam wasn’t that large.
They drove in silence. No one seemed ready to talk yet. When they got to Rick and Peg’s ranch house, they went inside. Liv and Adam had moved out when they adulted, but were temporarily staying there.
They all went into the living room, sat, and consulted with their own thoughts.
Finally, Liv broke the silence. “I’m not sure I’m comfortable making this decision.”
Rick nodded. “That’s okay, that can be our answer. We can leave it up to the judge. And we have a year to think about it, so we don’t make a decision that will haunt us.”
“I don’t need a year! I think we should kill the bastard,” Adam snarled. “Just like he killed her.” He was sitting upright on a chair that usually was good for relaxing in.
Everyone jerked in response.
“That’s an option,” Rick said.
“This is so weird,” Peg said softly. “I never thought this would happen to us.”
“No one would,” Rick said.
Adam slapped his palm on his leg. “He should be killed!”
Then Liv, sitting in a chair in front of the fireplace, said. “I understand what you say, but then what does that make us if we kill someone?”
“I don’t care!” he said hotly.
Her lips tightened, but she didn’t back down. “We would be the same as him.”
He shot a look at her. “No, we would not be an asshole who kills his own wife, in cold blood, leaving their young daughter to live without her mother.”
“Ex-wife,” Liv said quietly.
“Yes, that’s probably why she left him. She knew he was a horrible person.”
“Maybe, we’ll never know,” Liv said. “And now, we don’t have my sis…” she choked, unable to finish the sentence.
“I don’t know how I feel about this being our decision, either,” Peg said after a moment.
“It’s like I said,” Rick answered. “Our decision can be that we choose not to make the decision. This is just an opportunity they have given us for closure for our loss.”
“Our loss…” Peg choked.
“I don’t get how this happened,” Liv said. “Why do we even have this option? I don’t follow politics. It’s too distressing.”
“It was the billionaire pedophiles,” Adam said, anger still coloring his words.
“Yeah, after Epstein, other billionaires were found to be hosting parties on islands for other billionaires to rape and sexually molest young girls …” Rick started to say, “… and boys …”
“Not just billionaires. Politicians, and judges …” Adam interjected.
Rick nodded. “Including a Supreme Court judge. And they had tapes proving it. Two former Presidents, one from each side of the aisle, were caught on tape raping young girls. This finally got both parties in an uproar and it was the thing needed to actually get everyone to cooperate because everybody was furious!”
“And then they dug into the clergy sexual abuses, where the church actually would move sexual predator priests to other parishes without warning anyone,” Peg said, sniffling.
Adam nodded. “So they passed laws mimicking Sharia law where they could amputate someone’s hands if they were caught stealing. But they did it for sexual pedophilia instead.”
“But only if there was completely no doubt,” Rick said. “Otherwise a lighter sentence was imposed, just in case the defendant was later found not to be guilty.”
Adam grinned. “So if a billionaire or anyone else rapes your daughter, and is proven beyond doubt to be guilty, the family can make the decision on whether the felon should just go to jail, or go to jail and also have his junk cut off.”
“His junk?” Liv asked.
“Yeah, rape a kid and your penis is amputated. Maybe this would be the deterrent we need.” Adam said.
Rick nodded. “And when the billionaires got caught, it became very popular. Several high profile public figures.” He grinned. “Well, let’s say they got to experience it.”
“And it made the news. It was made public.” Adam grinned too.
“I don’t know,” Liv said. “The death penalty doesn’t appear to stop people from murdering.” She choked again, and tears started flowing again. Peg got up, sat next to her and hugged her.
“We don’t know that,” Adam answered. “We might have twice the murders without it. Besides, it helps the family with closure. When they decided to amend the law to also include first degree murders, now we can’t have some weak judge just sticking them in jail, where they can read, lift weights, get tattoos, hang with other felons and be eligible for parole in the future.”
“So we can decide Sco… I can’t say his name … is to be put to death,” Peg said.
“We can even push the death button ourselves,” Adam growled.
“I wouldn’t, couldn’t…” Peg started to say.
“Don’t worry, I’d handle it,” Adam interrupted.
“I don’t think the death option is the best idea,” Rick said quietly.
Adam’s head whipped around, “Why?”
Rick calmly looked him in the eyes. “First, because what would we say to Mia as she gets older and asks what happened to her father? Tell her we had him killed?”
Peg gasped. “No.”
Adam’s face changed as he thought that over. “Well … I guess…” He didn’t complete the sentence but you could see his mind was racing.
Then Rick said grimly, “And he wouldn’t pay the price he needs to pay.”
“What do you mean?” Liv asked.
Rick’s face was suffused with anger. “Because he would be dead. He wouldn’t be in torment. He wouldn’t be suffering. It would be like putting your pet to sleep. One that you loved.” His jaw tightened and he could barely continue. “I want him to pay for what he did.”
Peg looked over from where she and Liv were still clinging to each other.
“What do you have in mind?”
***
A year later
Peg was pushing Rick’s wheelchair because he had injured his shoulder playing with their dog. Adam and Liv strode behind them, their mood somber, as they approached the courthouse.
“Ah, finally getting this over,” Liv sighed. She took Adam’s arm.
“You didn’t have to come,” Rick said over his shoulder.
“We’re family,” Adam answered. “We do this together.”
“He’ll be in the courtroom,” Rick pointed out.
“Good,” Adam snarled. “I want to see his face when he hears our decision.”
Rick nodded.
Liv and Peg said nothing, but their faces indicated their agreement.
They entered the building and looked at the end of the hall where some numbers signified which hallway they needed to go to the assigned courtroom for their case. An arrow pointed right. They walked and rolled down the hallway, looking at the room numbers as they passed doors with small glass windows on them. Benches were scattered down the hallway for when attorneys and their clients needed to talk outside the courtrooms, or for people waiting for their own time to go inside, or to wait until someone was done using the restroom.
They finally found the room. Liv opened the door and Peg wheeled Rick inside with Adam following. The room was large with a couple of doors in the back, a high podium for the judge and two long tables for the opposing attorneys in front of the gates that led to the spectator area. The judge’s platform extended left to another desk for the bailiff seat next to a witness chair. In front of the defendant’s chair was a desk for the court reporter. The jury section was on the right wall.
The room was empty, so they paused, wondering where they should sit. Rick didn’t wonder that, but wondered where his chair should be wheeled.
Then the door opened behind them again, and Bob, who had been their court-appointed counselor to give them guidance and advice, entered.
“Sorry I’m late,” he said. “You’ll be sitting up here next to me.” The small but pleasant man led them up the aisle in the middle of the room and opened the small wooden gate. They walked and wheeled past him, and went to the attorney table on the left side where he pointed. He put his briefcase on the table in front of the seat closest to the middle aisle, so they found chairs and sat down.
Bob was still standing. “We will be seated here, the defendant…”
“He’s not a defendant, he was found guilty,” Adam interrupted.
Bob blinked behind his thick glasses. “Oh, right, you’re right. Sorry. Ahem, the convicted felon will be seated at the other table.” He motioned behind him, then he looked back at them. “Again, I am so sorry for your loss. I hope this gives you some closure.”
Rick nodded, but no one else said anything. They were all burnt out on the ‘sorry for your loss’ statements over the last year-plus. It just didn’t resonate anymore.
When no one else said anything, Bob nodded and sat down with them. “We’ll see the bailiff first, then the convict will be brought out and then the judge. No jury.”
There was the sound of the door opening again, and they turned and watched as several news reporters came in. Fortunately, cameras weren’t allowed. The reporters looked with a mixture of professional curiosity and some sympathy at the family. They sat and several of them started writing, occasionally looking over at them.
Rick blew out air, and turned away to ignore them. Publicizing this helped, hopefully, in this kind of event helping deter crime, so the press was necessary. Peg refused to look in their direction.
Everyone sat. Then one of the doors in the back opened and the bailiff came in. The other door opened and the court reporter entered. They both found their seats.
A few moments passed.
Then the door the court reporter had come through opened again, and Liv gasped, Peg whimpered, Adam did some kind of a growl and Rick just looked stony faced as an armed police officer entered, escorting the convicted murderer, Scott. His arms were handcuffed in front of him and he wore an orange jumpsuit. Another policeman was holding his elbow and directed him to the defendant table. He was not so kindly shoved into a chair and the two cops took up positions behind him.
Rick realized he was holding his breath, and let it out. Peg and Liv did the same. Adam didn’t, so either he had forgotten to breathe or he was breathing more softly.
Scott looked disheveled, his hair a mess and he refused to look at the family of the person he had murdered. He just sat and looked down at the desk.
Moments passed.
Finally, the door the bailiff had entered though opened again, and the judge entered. She was wearing the normal judge outfit, and had wavy black hair, light makeup and thick glasses.
“All rise,” the bailiff announced.
Everyone except Rick stood.
“Court is now in session, the Honorable Judge Enfield presiding.”
The judge whisked to her seat and sat.
“You may be seated,” the bailiff intoned.
After they sat, the Judge looked at the family, a look of sympathy on her face. Then she looked at the convict with absolutely no sympathy. Then back to the family. “This is a court session but it isn’t a trial, so I’m not going to be as formal. You are allowed to ask questions if you have any. There will be no responses allowed by the defendant, who is only here to learn the assessed penalty. The defendant will not be allowed to plead his position as there was a method provided for this in the one-year waiting period. Do you have any questions?”
They all shook their heads negatively.
The judge leaned back. “Okay. You were given the choice to provide the sentence in writing or verbally. I understand you have chosen verbally.”
Nods this time.
The judge nodded back. “Okay, who is designated to provide your sentence under Article Four of the Epstein Amendment for families and aggrieved parties to declare the punishment to the convicted felon?”
“I’m… um…” Rick’s voice faltered a bit. He cleared his throat and said in a stronger voice. “I am.”
“Okay, what does your family assess as the penalty for murder in this case?”
Rick cleared his throat again. Then he looked down at something he and the family had written together. Finally, he said, “We have decided against the death penalty.”
There was an astonished gasp from Scott, who obviously had expected the guillotine.
The reporters were scribbling frantically.
Rick ignored them, and continued. “As punishment, we have decided that the convict…”
His voice faltered again, and Peg gave him a hug. This helped and he continued. “We have decided that the convict will serve life in prison … as a paraplegic.”
A gasp. More furious writing by the press.
“Our understanding is that a shot can be induced that will totally immobilize the convict’s lower body, adversely affect his body’s core and severely hamper his hand strength. We also decree that he will be afforded no outside or professional caregiving and that any of his help must be administered by his fellow inmates.”
Another gasp by Scott. The family ignored him again.
The judge looked at Rick in his wheelchair.
Then she said, “So rules the Court.”
[Image Credit : Photo by Robert Clark on Unsplash]

After suffering a spinal injury, Norm started writing dystopian short stories featuring the theme of disability. Prior to his injury, he had written a dozen novels, and he is an award-winning business columnist. Some of his other disability short stories have or will soon be published in the magazines Amazing Stories, Bewildering Stories, Disabled Tales, Breath & Shadow, The Globe Review, Journ-E and Altered Reality. His website is : www.normcowie.com

0 Comments